The American criminal justice system has been experiencing severe scrutiny for some time.
The balance between individual rights and public safety is a major concern for people in the United States, especially when it comes to bail and pretrial release.
Many States have implemented laws aimed at trying to achieve this equilibrium with California being at the forefront of bail reform in the most recent years – aiming to strike a stability between protecting public safety and preserving the rights of those accused of a crime.
But does this system really work?
Depends on how you look at it.
The debate over pretrial release and bail has been a contentious one, with arguments on both sides weighing heavily on the scales of justice.
Let’s explore this complex issue a little further.
The Balance Between Bail and PreTrial Release
Bail has a long history in California, going back to the state’s first criminal statutes in the mid-1800s.
Originally, bail was designed as a way to ensure that accused individuals showed up for their court dates.
Over the years, the system has evolved into one that heavily relies on cash bail, which allows defendants to pay a predetermined amount to secure their release from custody, often regardless of the risk they pose to public safety.
As it stands, those who can afford bail can secure their release, while lower-income individuals remain in custody, often because they cannot afford to pay.
This has led to overcrowding in jails and prisons, as well as a disproportionate impact on people of color and those from low-income communities.
However, not everyone supports the move away from cash bail.
Some argue that risk assessments are flawed and can lead to unfair detention of those who pose little risk, while others have concerns that it may lead to the release of dangerous individuals.
So what can be done to bring balance?
According to Chief Justice Cantil-Sakauye in 2019, “across California and the nation, pretrial release and detention primarily based on cash bail are slowly being replaced with safer and fairer alternatives.”
What is Pretrial Release?
Pretrial Release refers to the release of an accused person, who has been booked into custody, before trial, with charges pending.
This occurs with or without conditions and is an important aspect of the criminal justice system as it allows individuals to be temporarily freed while awaiting their day in court.
How Does Pretrial Release Affect Public Safety?
There are several factors that are taken into consideration by the Court when determining whether someone is eligible for pretrial release including the severity of the crime committed, their criminal record, and ties to the community, such as family or employment, and whether they’re likely to flee if released.
If the defendant is a danger to the community, pretrial release could jeopardize public safety by potentially bringing a recurrence of violence back into the community from the same individual.
The decision to grant or deny bail is an often-complicated process full of nuances depending on the state, the legal situation, and other factors.
At the end of the day, the goal remains the same: to balance public safety with individual rights while ensuring a fair trial can take place.
Need assistance? Contact our office today!