The issue of money bail has been a hot topic in criminal justice reform conversations for years.
Many criminal justice experts and activists have argued that money bail unfairly targets low-income individuals and communities of color and perpetuates a system of mass incarceration.
However, opponents of bail reform have argued that eliminating money bail would make communities less safe by allowing dangerous criminals to be released before their trial.
But what does the research say?
Is money bail really necessary to keep communities safe?
The evidence is clear: it’s not.
What Are Some Reasons Behind This Assertion?
- Economic Inequality and the Bail System – One of the primary reasons why money bail fails to enhance community safety is its inherent bias against individuals with limited financial resources.
Research has consistently shown that those who cannot afford to pay bail often spend extended periods in jail awaiting trial.
This pretrial detention can have devastating consequences, including the loss of employment, housing, and even custody of their children.
As a result, money bail perpetuates a cycle of poverty, making it more challenging for these individuals to reintegrate into society, even if they are eventually found innocent.
- No Correlation Between Money Bail and Public Safety – Despite the longstanding belief that money bail keeps dangerous individuals off the streets, research consistently demonstrates that there is no significant correlation between the amount of bail paid and public safety.
A study conducted by the Arnold Foundation found that individuals who were detained pretrial were no more likely to be convicted or receive harsher sentences than those who were released before trial.
In other words, detaining people solely based on their inability to pay bail does not make communities safer.
- Alternatives to Money Bail – Research has shown that alternatives to money bail, such as risk assessment tools and community supervision, can be more effective in ensuring court appearances and public safety.
These approaches focus on assessing an individual’s risk of flight or committing new crimes, rather than their financial resources.
By using data-driven methods to determine release conditions, the criminal justice system can better protect public safety without discriminating against the economically disadvantaged.
- Shifting Towards Reform -The undeniable evidence that money bail doesn’t make communities safer has prompted many jurisdictions to rethink their approach to pretrial detention.
Several states have already taken steps to reform their bail systems, with some eliminating money bail altogether. These changes aim to reduce the impact of economic inequality on pretrial detention and to create a more equitable and just system.
The evidence is clear: money bail is neither effective nor fair.
It’s time for our society to step up and embrace change. This isn’t just about policy, it’s about our morals and ethics.
We need a system that treats everyone fairly and equally when it comes to pretrial justice.
Need assistance? Contact the office today!